Drones carrying defibrillators could arrive ahead of ambulances at hundreds of cardiac arrest incidents each year, potentially creating opportunities for earlier treatment, according to new research.
The study, published in the industrial journal Reliability Engineering & System Safety, also found they could improve emergency response coverage in parts of Scotland.
The University of Strathclyde-led research modelled networks of drones capable of rapidly delivering automated external defibrillators (AEDs) to people experiencing an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.
Rapid intervention
More than 3,000 people experience an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in Scotland each year. Rapid intervention is critical, with previous studies suggesting that a patient’s chance of survival falls by around 7% to 10% for every minute without intervention.
Using real Scottish cardiac arrest and ambulance response data, researchers found that a modelled drone network covering NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde could make around 490 deliveries a year in which a drone would arrive at least one minute before an ambulance.
In NHS Grampian, which includes large rural areas where emergency response can be more challenging, drones were estimated to arrive at least one minute ahead of an ambulance in around 195 cases a year.
Defibrillator delivery
The modelling, which focused on defibrillator delivery rather than treatment, also indicated that drones could substantially increase the proportion of cardiac arrest incidents where an AED could be delivered within six minutes.
In Greater Glasgow and Clyde, recorded ambulance data showed that 24% of cardiac arrest incidents received a response within six minutes. The modelled drone network could deliver a defibrillator within that time in 86% of cases, with an average estimated drone response time of 4.01 minutes.
In Grampian, the equivalent figures were 32% for recorded ambulance responses and 77% for modelled drone deliveries, with an average estimated drone response time of 4.33 minutes.
The researchers emphasise that earlier delivery would not necessarily translate into earlier treatment, which would depend on factors including the availability and ability of bystanders to use the equipment.
New method
The research paper also involved the Scottish Ambulance Service and Nato’s Centre for Maritime Research & Experimentation, developed a new method for identifying where defibrillator-carrying drones could be based to provide the most reliable coverage.
Rather than simply calculating the distance a drone could travel, the researchers accounted for uncertainties that could affect a network operating in real-world conditions, including variations in ambulance response times, Scottish wind conditions, drone flight times and battery consumption. The modelling also incorporated geographical factors and no-fly zones.
The approach prioritised areas where existing emergency medical service coverage was more limited while identifying locations from which drones would have the greatest probability of reaching patients rapidly.
Professor Edoardo Patelli, Head of the Centre for Intelligent Infrastructure at Strathclyde, and corresponding author of the study, said: “The results suggest that a carefully designed network could considerably increase the number of cardiac arrest incidents reached within six minutes, both in densely populated areas such as Greater Glasgow and Clyde and in more rural regions such as Grampian.
“The study has not simply assumed that a drone can reach every patient within a certain distance. Our approach takes account of uncertainties including Scotland’s weather, variations in ambulance response times and drone performance and battery capacity.”
“Drones would not replace ambulances or paramedics, but rather have the potential to complement the emergency response by delivering a defibrillator rapidly during the critical minutes before an ambulance arrives.”
Enhance care
Professor Paul Gowens, Associate Director, Research and Innovation at the Scottish Ambulance Service, said: “Drone-enabled defibrillator delivery has the potential to support our crews and enhance patient care. Our involvement in drone modelling projects identifies the need for clinical expertise to be built into the guidance from the outset, helping to ensure it’s practical, safe and aligned with real world pre-hospital and emergency response needs.
“The success of early access to defibrillation could be improved by the use of drones, however the use of that defibrillator by bystanders is the key element in that part of the chain of survival.”
While the modelling indicates that drones could improve access to defibrillators, further evaluation is needed to establish how effectively such a system could operate in practice and whether earlier delivery would improve patient outcomes.
The paper comes in the wake of the pioneering Project CAELUS, which aimed to revolutionise healthcare logistics and was built on research developed in the Aerospace Centre of Excellence at the University of Strathclyde.